An unabashed and life-long anime fan, comic book reader, and avid video game player, Spencer believes in supporting every claim with evidence and that Wally West is the best Flash of all time. But if Vic does appeal, Lemoine believes that the Court of Appeals will rule in the same manner. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new window), Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window), Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window), Click to share on Skype (Opens in new window), Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window), New WandaVision Rumor Claims The First X-Men Will Be Introduced Through The Show, Godzilla vs. Kong Fan Makes A Fearsome Godzilla Snowman, Alec Baldwin Reveals Gruesome Dream Of Executing President Donald Trump, Star Trek: Discovery Actress Mary Wiseman Confirms She Is “Queer and Proud”, engaging in a friendly manner with Mignogna. A firsthand account of this encounter has never been put forth by Price. Almost all of his con appearances this year have been canceled, he's fired from RWBY , and Funimation cut their ties with him . Related: Vic Mignogna to Reportedly “Appeal Every Single Dismissed Cause of Action” in Dismissed Defamation Lawsuit. Update: Following the publishing of this article, Plant provided Bounding into Comics with a link to a Facebook post by Perry, in which she shared a link to Plant’s “Vic Mignogna: A Love Story” post on Tumblr, where Price commented on how Mignogna “can’t comprehend how anyone wouldn’t be flattered by his advances.” She added that she “just wanted to point out the depth of his creepiness.”, “oblivious is too kind. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new window), Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window), Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window), Click to share on Skype (Opens in new window), Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window), New WandaVision Rumor Claims The First X-Men Will Be Introduced Through The Show, Godzilla vs. Kong Fan Makes A Fearsome Godzilla Snowman, Alec Baldwin Reveals Gruesome Dream Of Executing President Donald Trump, Star Trek: Discovery Actress Mary Wiseman Confirms She Is “Queer and Proud”, going to appeal every single dismissed cause of action, Funimation Offers Akira SD Blu-Ray Owners Free Upgrade to 4K Version, Report: AT&T Confirms Sale Of Crunchyroll To Sony’s Funimation for $1.17 Billion. Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. However, critics have noted several inconsistencies within Plant’s story, such as how he took no action in defense of Price following the alleged assault, did not alert convention security or other authorities, was engaging in a friendly manner with Mignogna on Twitter on either the day after or night of the alleged assault. Hello, and welcome to this Special Episode of Fire Fox News Channel, regarding Vic Mignogna's case. The appeal will be heard by the Second District Court Of Appeals. star_border Follow. Mignogna filed an appeal on October 24, with a hearing set for November 21. By subscribing, you agree to receive email communication from Bounding Into Comics. Disclosure Information: Some of the organizations with products on our site may pay us a referral fee or affiliate commission when you click to apply for those products. SA Forums (1/2), — Emmett Initiative (@Emm_Initiative) December 11, 2019, 2/2 Alternately, he could simply reach out to the woman I saw him grab without her consent and apologize for his weird and inappropriate behavior. So, any updates on the appeal after Vic's brief? Anime voice actor Vic Mignogna loses big as judge drops final claims that Dallas-area studio and colleagues defamed him Tarrant County judge's action came … However, allowing the Plaintiff to effectively ambush the Defendants with a late filed pleading—even absent its attached evidence—furthers the Plaintiff’s improper strategy. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! Search Amazon.com: Purchase: Account - Platinum Upgrade - New Avatar - Other's Avatar - Archives - No-Ads - New Username - Banner Advertisement - Smilie - Stick Thread - Gift Cert. Monica Rial, Ron Toye, Jamie Marchi, Funimation File Motion to Dismiss Vic Mignogna's Appeal posted on 2019-10-30 16:00 EDT by Rafael Antonio Pineda Mignogna filed appeal on October 24. With this denial, Mignogna’s appeal against the initial dismissal of his causes of action will be allowed to move forward. This allegedly resulted in Orion Envy’s, a Star Trek-themed dance group of which Price was a member, instituting a ‘buddy-system’ to ensure that no one was alone with Mignogna. He hopes that Vic Mignogna will accept the ruling and not file for an appeal. Copyright 2018, Bounding Into Comics. If he did that and she accepted his apology, I’d have no reason to talk about @vicmignogna ever again. Vic Mignogna was born on August 27, 1962 in Greensburg, Pennsylvania, USA as Victor Joseph Mignogna. On December 11th, the court denied the Motion to Dismiss Appeal for Lack of Subject Matter Jurisdiction and as Premature, previously filed by attorney J. Sean Lemoine on behalf of Rial and Toye which sought to dismiss Mignogna’s appeal on the grounds that it was filed prematurely. Netflix recently acquired the JoJo's Bizarre Adventure spinoff OVA series, Thus Spoke Kishibe Rohan, and plans to stream it in Spring 2021. ( Thank you Kurono! Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. Here’s the same from my Facebook messenger client. In the affidavit, Plant repeats his claims from his previously written account, titled Vic Mignogna: A Love Story, which states that Mignogna violently pulled the hair of cosplayer Dayna Price and proceeded to “hiss something” in her ear, at Bayou Con 2013. March 4, 2020 April 30, 2020. Anime Anime News Discussion monica rial News ron toye tamaki suoh voice actor japanese Vic Mignogna vic mignogna appeal vic mignogna broly vic mignogna monica rial judge chupp vic mignogna rwby. Keep in mind that he was engaged at the time and that later in the evening a “friend” of his showed up that I am 99% sure was an escort.”, “of course we do . He is known for his work on Star Trek Continues (2013), Fullmetal Alchemist: The Sacred Star of Milos (2011) and Star Trek Continues: The Vignettes (2012). VIC MIGNOGNA Case Status and Appeal Brief SUMMARY - YouTube Emperor Pyros. what kinda of lawyer aims for appeal? By subscribing, you agree to receive email communication from Bounding Into Comics. The Court of Appeals in the Second Appellate District of Texas has denied a request by Monica Rial and Ron Toye to dismiss Vic Mignogna’s appeal, allowing for the case to move forward in the appeals process. For the past year, anime fans have been embroiled in a conflict over voice actor Vic Mignogna.Funimation and Rooster Teeth cut ties with the Mignogna, famous for roles in Fullmetal Alchemist, Dragon Ball Z, Ouran Host Club and RWBY, after several fans and other voice actors accused him of sexual misconduct.Rumors have swirled around Mignogna for years among older anime fans, … by Roland Kelts. I just wanted to point out the depth of his creepiness to people who may not have first hand experience.”, Plant has also shared a message, allegedly between himself and a member of the Orion’s Envy dance group on the night after the alleged incident, on his Twitter account, in which Plant apologized that the member “had to deal with Malfoy,” noting that they referred to Mignogna as “a Slytherin because of his weird hissing.”, Yup. Dragon Ball Broly’s New VA Johnny Yong Bosch Reveals Toei Approached Him Directly To Take Over Role from Vic Mignogna! On December 11 th, the court denied the Motion to Dismiss Appeal for Lack of Subject Matter Jurisdiction and as Premature, previously filed by attorney J. Sean Lemoine on behalf of Rial and Toye which sought to dismiss Mignogna’s appeal on the grounds that it was filed prematurely. Vic Mignogna spent the past two decades building a career as a voice actor. Thus Spoke Kishibe Rohan: Who Should Voice the Title Role in the Netflix Dub? Emmett PlantMonica RialNick RekietaRon ToyeVic Mignogna. Monica Rial, Jamie Marchi, and the other members of the Defense Team's Appeal to Mr. Mignogna's Appeal was denied, as shown in the statement below. Leave a Reply Cancel reply. Anime News. According to multiple sources, the allegations arose on January 16th on Twitter, where Mignogna was accused of homophobia, rude behavior, and unwanted physical advances during conventions meet … Rial, Marchi, Toye, and Funimation filed a motion on October 24 to dismiss Mignogna's appeal for review of the Tarrant County District Court's decision to dismiss Mignogna… Vic Mignogna is legally a piece of shit and the terrible SLAPP lawsuit. Over the past month, all of that work and goodwill was maliciously and brutally destroyed by a dedicated group hell-bent on dragging his name and reputation into oblivion. Stream Clip: Summary of Vic Mignogna's Appeal Status - YouTube Without a clear exclusion of the petition, as well as the evidence, Plaintiff will undoubtedly attempt to rely on the Second Amended Petition on appeal. The due date for the brief was originally due by January 27, 2020. Related: Days After Being Announced as Dragon Ball’s New Broly Voice Actor, Johnny Yong Bosch Shuts Down Accusations of Sexual Misconduct. A Summary So Far! Hello, and welcome to this Special Episode of Fire Fox News Channel, regarding Vic Mignogna's case. Additionally, a hearing for Funimation, Marchi, Rial and Toye to request “Sanctions and Attorney’s Fees” has been set for November 21st, 2019 at 10:30 AM. Monica Rial, Jamie Marchi, and the other members of the Defense Team's Appeal to Mr. Mignogna's Appeal was denied, as shown in the statement below. An unabashed and life-long anime fan, comic book reader, and avid video game player, Spencer believes in supporting every claim with evidence and that Wally West is the best Flash of all time. Upon receiving news that Mignogna had filed to appeal, J. Sean Lemoine, the attorney representing Rial and Toye, penned a letter to Judge Chupp accusing the appeal of being “legally improper” and noted his intent to “file a Motion to dismiss as soon as the clerk issues a cause number.”, Related: Court Dismisses Dragon Ball Super: Broly Voice Actor Vic Mignogna’s Remaining Claims Against Defendants in Defamation Lawsuit. Chupp later … Lemoine accused the filing of impropriety, due to it being filed before a “final judgement” had been made on said sanctions and attorney’s fees: “As Plaintiff acknowledges in his Notice of Appeal, he does not appeal a final judgment (“Vic desires to appeal the Order Granting Defendants’ [Motions to Dismiss] (and all orders granting fees, costs or sanctions thereafter).” Emphasis added. Dragon Ball Voice Actress Monica Rial to Star As Uzaki Hana in Funimation Dub of Uzaki-Chan Wants to Hang Out. Vic files Notice Of Appeal, Rial/Toye file notice of hearing for sanctions, letter to Chupp (10-24-2019) Vic filed a notice of appeal. 10/24 – the appeal has been electronically filed pic.twitter.com/WiqwLpE78T. Ty and I discuss Ron's tweets and how they could impact Vic's case if it comes back on appeal. vic mignogna appeal. This past week, sexual assault allegations and claims arose against Vic Mignogna, a well-known anime voice actor in series such as Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, Dragon Ball Super: Broly, and Ouron High School Host Club. Culture | CULTURE SMASH Mar 10, 2019. He could be honest and tell them that I haven’t lied and that my testimony is true, and encourage them to resolve this matter before it goes to court. Dragon Ball actor Vic Mignogna was ordered to pay nearly $250,000 in legal fees and sanctions as a result of his failed recent defamation lawsuits. So a fan hit me up on email recently, asking for my thoughts on what's been going on with the Vic Mignogna Lawsuit. The Vic Mignogna/Funimation Lawsuit! It is like going to a doctor that aims to beat cancer after it reappears after remission Learn how your comment data is processed. Or is this whole thing on hold? Vic Mignogna. This news was publicly announced by attorney and YouTube host Nick Rekieta, who also used the announcement to mock the many legal experts on Twitter who were confident that the appeal would be dismissed: On the same day as the Motion to Dismiss was denied, Star Trek audio book producer and i09.com contributor Emmett Plant threatened “a lot of Vic Mignogna’s fans” with potential lawsuits due to accusations that he committed perjury in the sworn affidavit submitted by Plant to the court in defense of the defendants: A lot of @vicmignogna‘s fans are about to get letters from my lawyers for accusing me of perjury (if they haven’t already). A ruling on the objection raised as to the filing of the Second Amended Petition would also allow the Court of Appeals to determine if Plaintiff’s tactics are appropriate, and also avoid remand on this issue.”, A copy of this letter was also issued to “all counsel of record.”, FunimationJamie MarchiMonica RialRon ToyeVic Mignogna. Critics also note that Plant’s account is supported solely by his girlfriend, Neysha Perry, with whom Plant admits he “would have never forged a friendship that became a romantic relationship without Vic’s stupid and inappropriate behavior” during this alleged incident. #MeToo allegations roil U.S. anime conventions. According to the Dallas News opinion journalist who attended the hearing, Sharon Grigsby, this first round of dismissals by Chupp occurred after Vic’s attorney, Ty Beard, failed to provide the “clear and specific evidence” that was required t… Perhaps unaware of the heated passions in the anime community surrounding this case, on September 6, 2019, Judge Chupp dismissed 12 of Vic Mignogna’s 17 claims against the Defendants. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Copyright 2018, Bounding Into Comics. Stream Clip: Ty Beard on Ron's Tweets and Vic Mignogna's Appeal. He can be found on Twitter @kabutoridermav. Spencer is the Associate Editor for Bounding Into Comics. Disclosure Information: Some of the organizations with products on our site may pay us a referral fee or affiliate commission when you click to apply for those products. It has reported that Judge John P. Chupp called a hearing in Tarrant County District Court, ordering Vic Mignogna's attorneys Ty Beard and An Lee Hsu to mediate an agreement with Funimation, Monica Rial, and Ron Toye's attorneys Sean Lemoine, Ethan Minshull, Casey S. Erick, Andrea Perez, and John Volney by October 3. The request will be heard before Judge John P. Chupp, the Tarrant County judge who previously ruled to dismiss all of Mignogna’s causes of action. - Donations! He can be found on Twitter @kabutoridermav. Vic Mignogna, Actor: Star Trek Continues. share Share. Vic Mignogna's been a big anime voice actor for a long time and recently he's been under fire for sexual harassment/assault and other inappropriate exchanges between his fans and other voice actors. ).”, Lemoine also requests that “the Court enter an Order on Defendants’ Omnibus Objections to Plaintiff’s TCPA Evidence” and that “the Court strike the Second Amended Petition in its entirety” due to his belief that “Plaintiff will undoubtedly attempt to rely on the Second Amended Petition on appeal.”, “Again, we agree that the Court correctly noted in the Order that it excluded the attachments to the Second Amended Petition. A brief update on the Vic Mignogna litigation; As you probably know, Vic Mignogna and his council are appealing the results of the litigation from 2019. $238,042.42 is what Vic owes now, ignoring the sanctions that are conditioned on appeal $145,500.00 is the baseline appeal-conditioned sanctions that Vic might already owe simply because Percy is an idiot and he already filed a premature Notice of Appeal … He has such a huge ego that he can’t comprehend how anyone wouldn’t be flattered by his advances. Mignogna’s appeal was first hinted at by attorney and YouTube host Nick Rekieta who stated that Mignogna was “going to appeal every single dismissed cause of action.”, Related: Vic Mignogna to Reportedly “Appeal Every Single Dismissed Cause of Action” in Dismissed Defamation Lawsuit. Spencer is the Associate Editor for Bounding Into Comics. By … (Updated 2 p.m. 11/25/19: State District Judge John Chupp awarded about $370,000 in defense attorney’s fees and sanctions against Vic Mignogna on Monday. Vic will be appealing the TCPA ruling that dismissed his lawsuit on October 4th, including any fees and sanctions related to the ruling. There is currently some speculation as to whether Samuel Johnson is filing this notice early, in preparation for a long appeal process throughout the year. Mignogna’s appeal has now been confirmed, with an October 24th filing stating that Mignogna will appeal the decision to the Texas Second District Court of Appeals. https://t.co/RDVbNIvAt4 pic.twitter.com/B8b9POyXM2, — Emmett Initiative (@Emm_Initiative) December 14, 2019. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! Over the past two months, the #MeToo movement breached … Related: Vic Mignogna Files to Begin Appeals Process Against Dismissal of Defamation Lawsuit. The filing for extension appears to request an extension to February 18, 2020. After having every cause of action dismissed in his defamation lawsuit against Funimation, Jamie Marchi, Monica Rial and Ron Toye, Dragon Ball Super: Broly voice actor Vic Mignogna has officially filed to appeal the dismissal ruling. Mignogna’s appeal has now been confirmed, with an October 24 th filing stating that Mignogna will appeal the decision to the Texas Second District Court of Appeals. (2/2), Johnny Young Bosch Revealed as Broly’s New Voice Actor in Dragon Ball FighterZ, Replacing Vic Mignogna. Chupp also ruled that Mignogna will have to pay an additional $587,500 USD in contingent fees should he choose to appeal. He worked with great people, made great friends, and represented great companies. , Lemoine believes that the Court of Appeals appealing the TCPA ruling that his... Denial, Mignogna ’ s New Voice actor back on appeal impact Vic 's brief he has a... ” in Dismissed Defamation Lawsuit with a hearing set for November 21 Mignogna the! 'S Tweets and how they could impact Vic 's brief on the appeal will be the! ’ d have no reason to talk about @ vicmignogna ever again Mignogna ’ s New Johnny... Every Single Dismissed Cause of Action will be allowed to move forward by Price, with a set! Wants to Hang Out Mignogna filed an appeal on October 24, with a hearing set for 21!, made great friends, and represented great companies Replacing Vic Mignogna you agree receive! Any fees and sanctions related to the ruling for extension appears to request an extension February... Tweets and Vic Mignogna is legally a piece of shit and the SLAPP... Believes that the Court of Appeals Dismissed Cause of Action ” in Dismissed Defamation Lawsuit Rohan Who! Originally due by January 27, 2020 January 27, 2020 a Voice actor Every Single Dismissed Cause Action... Sorry, your blog can not share posts by email Appeals will rule in the same manner @. December 14, 2019 Vic Mignogna 's case subscribing, you agree to receive email communication from Bounding Into.. Clip: Ty Beard on Ron 's Tweets and how they could impact 's... S New VA Johnny Yong Bosch Reveals Toei Approached Him Directly to Take Over Role Vic... Set for November 21 Clip: Ty Beard on Ron 's Tweets and Vic.. Lawsuit on October 24, with a hearing set for November 21 a piece of shit the... Communication from Bounding Into Comics Facebook messenger client extension to February 18,.. Ron 's Tweets and Vic Mignogna Files to Begin Appeals Process against dismissal of his causes of Action ” Dismissed. And she accepted his apology, I ’ d have no reason to talk about @ vicmignogna ever again Joseph... Voice Actress Monica Rial to Star as Uzaki Hana in Funimation Dub Uzaki-Chan! Facebook messenger client Appeals will rule in the Netflix Dub Pennsylvania, USA as Victor Joseph.! For extension appears to request an extension to February 18, 2020 believes that the Court of will! In the same from my Facebook messenger client and Vic Mignogna to Reportedly “ appeal Every Dismissed... How anyone wouldn ’ t comprehend how anyone wouldn ’ t comprehend how anyone wouldn ’ t how! Tcpa ruling that Dismissed his Lawsuit on October 24, with a hearing set for November 21 Victor Joseph.! Uzaki-Chan Wants to Hang Out the Netflix Dub updates on the appeal will be appealing the TCPA that. Uzaki Hana in Funimation Dub of Uzaki-Chan Wants to Hang Out of Wants. Post was not sent - check your email addresses the ruling and sanctions related to the ruling a account. D have no reason to talk about @ vicmignogna ever again she accepted his apology, ’... Wouldn ’ t be flattered by his advances not share posts by email if it comes back on.. ( @ Emm_Initiative ) December 14, 2019, Replacing Vic Mignogna appeal will be the. Will be appealing the TCPA ruling that Dismissed his Lawsuit on October 24, with a hearing set November... Including any fees and sanctions related to the ruling ( 2/2 ), Johnny Bosch... If he did that and she accepted his apology, I ’ d have no reason talk! Associate Editor for Bounding Into Comics Yong Bosch Reveals Toei Approached Him Directly to Take Over Role from Mignogna. Appears to request an extension to February 18, 2020 Bounding Into Comics of Uzaki-Chan Wants to Hang Out,. Uzaki Hana in Funimation Dub of Uzaki-Chan Wants to Hang Out Special Episode of Fire Fox News Channel regarding! August 27, 2020 by email have no reason to talk about @ ever! Single Dismissed Cause of Action will be heard by the Second District Court of Appeals will rule the! Ruling that Dismissed his Lawsuit on October 24, with a hearing set November! //T.Co/Rdvbnivat4 pic.twitter.com/B8b9POyXM2, — Emmett Initiative ( @ Emm_Initiative ) December 14,.! The past two decades building a career as a Voice actor in dragon Ball FighterZ, Vic. Wouldn ’ t comprehend how anyone wouldn ’ t comprehend how anyone wouldn t! – the appeal has been electronically filed pic.twitter.com/WiqwLpE78T due date for the brief was vic mignogna appeal due by January,. The Netflix Dub vic mignogna appeal Bosch Reveals Toei Approached Him Directly to Take Role... I ’ d have no reason to talk about @ vicmignogna ever again originally... For Bounding Into Comics d have no reason to talk about @ vicmignogna again..., USA as Victor Joseph Mignogna: Who Should Voice the Title Role the... Filed an appeal on October 24, with a hearing set for November 21 dragon Ball Actress! Wouldn ’ t comprehend how anyone wouldn ’ t comprehend how anyone wouldn ’ comprehend..., you agree to receive email communication from Bounding Into Comics Lawsuit on October 24, with hearing. As Victor Joseph Mignogna it comes back on appeal: Ty Beard on Ron 's Tweets and Vic Files... Put forth by Price comes back on appeal Uzaki-Chan Wants to Hang Out regarding Vic Mignogna to Reportedly “ Every! Fighterz, Replacing Vic Mignogna to Reportedly “ appeal Every Single Dismissed Cause of Action will be appealing the ruling! The past two decades building a career as a Voice actor Mignogna filed an appeal on October 4th, any. D have no reason to talk about @ vicmignogna ever again career as a Voice.. Denial, Mignogna ’ s New VA Johnny Yong Bosch Reveals Toei Approached Directly... Extension to February 18, 2020 if it comes back on appeal Into Comics that and she his... On August 27, 2020 Files to Begin Appeals Process against dismissal of his causes of Action be... Of Defamation Lawsuit appealing the TCPA ruling that Dismissed his Lawsuit on 4th... New VA Johnny Yong Bosch Reveals Toei Approached Him Directly to Take Over Role from Vic Mignogna case... Against dismissal of Defamation Lawsuit related to the ruling Who Should Voice the Title Role in the same from Facebook... In Greensburg, Pennsylvania, USA as Victor Joseph Mignogna New VA Johnny Yong Bosch Reveals Toei Approached Directly. ’ d have no reason to talk about @ vicmignogna ever again the due date for the was! Vicmignogna ever again Rial to Star as Uzaki Hana in Funimation Dub of Uzaki-Chan Wants to Hang.! Forth by Price, you agree to receive email communication from Bounding Into Comics Revealed as Broly ’ s VA! That the Court of Appeals will rule in the same manner Joseph Mignogna Special Episode of Fire News!, USA as Victor Joseph Mignogna, made great friends, and welcome to this Special of... ’ d have no reason to talk about @ vicmignogna ever again apology, I d. Every Single Dismissed Cause of Action will be heard by the Second District Court of Appeals will rule in same! Decades building a career as a Voice actor October 4th, including any fees sanctions... Legally a piece of shit and the terrible SLAPP Lawsuit a hearing set for November.... This Special Episode of Fire Fox News Channel, regarding Vic Mignogna updates on the appeal after Vic 's.... Approached Him Directly to Take Over Role from Vic Mignogna Files to Begin Appeals Process against dismissal Defamation... Set for November 21 in dragon Ball Voice Actress Monica Rial to Star as Hana! Fire Fox News Channel, regarding Vic Mignogna to Reportedly “ appeal Every Single Cause... My Facebook messenger client of this encounter has never been put forth by Price of. A Voice actor in dragon Ball Voice Actress Monica Rial to Star as Uzaki Hana in Dub! Have no reason to talk about @ vicmignogna ever again Dub of Uzaki-Chan Wants to Hang.! Greensburg, Pennsylvania, USA as Victor Joseph Mignogna to move forward,. Born on August 27, 2020 the ruling – the appeal after Vic 's case Editor for Bounding Into....