... What is the significance of the Battle of the Alamo? Congress says, Hey, Davy, we really support you but we’re not going to send you any troops. I assume you are asking about the Texas Revolution, in which the Battle of the Alamo was one of the opening skirmishes. Texas’ Ted Poe probably remembered the Alamo more than anyone in Congress and seemed to love nothing more than to link the Alamo to the war on terrorism. Things had gotten a little tense. Very logical reasons,” said Cure. 4th grade. “The Mexicans won the battle of the Alamo,” said the man, and the crowd laughed. Santa Anna has got thousands of troops. The Battle of the Alamo DRAFT. Picture Davy Crockett at the Alamo. The question was asked, something along the lines of why didn’t the city preserve the Alamo intact as the city grew, and an answer was offered, which was something along the lines of because it just didn’t work out that way, and the man made a move to leave, not entirely satisfied nor surprised, before Collins spoke up with an impish tone. Texas aged 18-29 are the least likely to know Mexico won the Battle of the Alamo (43 percent), and the most likely to think Texas won (31 percent), that the United States won 10 percent), and to say they don’t know at 17 percent, which I suppose is a way of answering the question correctly. (In fact, he did not mention the Alamo in public as president.). This isn’t “kids today.” No one is getting off anyone’s lawn here. Learn about the 200 volunteer soldiers, including James Bowie, William Travis and Davy Crockett, who defended the Alamo from a Mexican force of thousands. This confusion over who won and how this plays out in racial and ethnic identity caused an awkward encounter at a packed event at the Texas Tribune Festival in September 2016 on the campus of the University of Texas. As he puts it, “Violence is an essential and necessary part of the process through which American society was established and through which its democratic values are defended and enforced.” In Slotkin’s telling, the violence is a feature, not a bug. Cure taught seventh grade Texas history for eight years in Round Rock, a suburb just north of Austin. The Alamo, he believed, didn’t have that feeling of an Independence Hall in Philadelphia, or the White House in Washington. www.patreon.com/battlestack - please support these videos!The Battle of the Alamo was fought in 1836 during the Texas Revolution. Nonprofit journalism for an informed community. Practice. April 22, 2019 J W Collins. The martyrdom at the Alamo justified, if not demanded, violent revenge, and something new was created, in this case, the Republic of Texas. The Mexicans won the battle, killing all of the Texan soldiers inside the fort. The one who looked out of place was the slouching man at the end in the black polo shirt and black trousers. The battle involved two hundred Texans, holed up in the old Alamo mission surrounded by two thousand Mexican troops, led by General Santa Anna.The Texans were led by Colonels Jim Bowie, William B. Travis, and Davy Crockett. The battle over how to redevelop the Alamo and remember the site’s history has provoked death threats and emerged as a cause célèbre among Texas’s network of … Every year, he always put on his final exam who won the Battle of the Alamo. Even with Civil War battlefields, at least someone in the United States won. The Battle of the Alamo was the catalyst behind the final push to be independent from Mexico, and is responsible for properly igniting the Texan people with Enlightenment ideas for their new nation. Getting this question wrong was consistent across our usual dividing lines, including sex, education, partisanship, and ideology. But the answer goes deeper than emphasis to what the battle represents these days in our popular imagination. Or can it be that the mysteries, myths and legen… No matter where you go in the world and you start talking, ‘Hey, where you from?’ if it’s a Texan the first thing they say is, ‘I’m a Texan.’ Have you noticed that? It took place at a fort in San Antonio, Texas called the Alamo. Play. But the fact of the matter is I’m an American, and I’m a Texan, and I view history through that, but I want to be honest about it because I think everybody has room at the table, and I want to be mature enough to say, yeah, I lost there, but guess what? And when George W. Bush needed Congress to approve a surge of 20,000 more troops in Iraq, debate in the House quickly, if not inevitably, devolved into an exercise in revisionist Texas history. Are you involved in development or open source activities in your personal capacity? “Thinking back, I would say he was racist,” she said. One of the survivors was Susanna W. Dickinson and her infant daughter, Angelina. Accordingly, who won the battle of the Alamo? Menéndez shrugged, put his right hand on his chest – over his heart, if you will – and said, “I’m an American.” Again, the crowd laughed, and not because anyone was trying to be funny. The Alamo was anything but: reviewers skewered it, John Wayne (its producer, director and major star), lost his shirt financing it, Hollywood ignored it... Related searches who won the battle of the alamo … The Battle of the Alamo was a costly win for Santa Anna: he lost about 600 soldiers that day, to some 200 rebellious Texans. sanantonioreport.org - Jason Stanford. Yes, thats another part. Follow him on Twitter at @JasStanford. Only two factors jump out in the cross tabs: age and race. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! The war ended in April of 1936, with the Battle of San Jancito. To play this quiz, please finish editing it. “Nobody wants to be the losers.”. Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), a packed event at the Texas Tribune Festival in September 2016, Harlandale urges students to switch to virtual learning for a short time, Long-term care facility residents begin receiving second doses of COVID-19 vaccination, Marketing data company Alliance laying off 50 San Antonio workers, Proudly powered by Newspack by Automattic. What are the qualifications of a parliamentary candidate? Solo Practice. In Texas, where gun ranges and liquor stores are considered essential businesses, believing that “cowering in fear” empowers the coronavirus is not uncommon. That’s what Stephen Cure thinks. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Edit. read more. “Why? In the complex was a seminary for the priests, a chapel, barracks for missionaries and their families and a textile workshop. “My question is related, but first I want to set the historical record correct. In the February 2020 UT/Texas Tribune poll, Henson asked Texans, in effect, if they were smarter than a seventh-grader: “Whose armed forces won the Battle of the Alamo in 1836?”. The Battle of the Alamo (February 23 – March 6, 1836) was a pivotal event in the Texas Revolution. You are now signed up to receive The Curve, sent each weekday evening. On Texas Independence Day 2005 – March 2 for the uninitiated – Poe called Santa Anna the “19th-century Saddam Hussein.”. Well, the best indicator might be how many combatants on each side were still alive at the end of the battle - the Texans had 0, the … In a lop-sided victory, the larger Mexican Army was thoroughly beaten in the battle of San Jacinto and Santa Anna was forced to surrender, securing Texas’ independence. What are the advantages and disadvantages of individual sports and team sports? Jason Stanford co-wrote, with Bryan Burrough and Chris Tomlinson, Forget the Alamo: The Rise and Fall of the American Myth, due out June 2021 from Penguin Books. The Battle of San Jacinto won independence for Texas. Other articles where Battle of the Alamo is discussed: Texas Revolution: Santa Anna responds: the Alamo and the Goliad Massacre: Determined to punish the rebellious Texans, whom he viewed as pirates who deserved to be executed, Santa Anna mounted a campaign to demonstrate his power by exacting the same kind of retribution upon them that he had visited upon Zacatecas.… In addition, sympathizers from the town of San Antonio across the river from the Alamo were sneaking in and out of the fort more or less continuously during the siege preceding the massacre, so there was no lack of Texan witnesses to the whole affair. It’s child’s play, literally, since state law mandates that every seventh-grader in Texas remember the Alamo. It’s also a tool people use to justify the United States going to war, and has been for a long time. The Battle of the Alamo DRAFT. One Mexican soldier had been killed and three others wounded, while only one Texian had been injured. Built around 1724 as a mission complex by the Spanish government, the Alamo was not just a single building but a group of them that spanned three acres and surrounded a central courtyard. The Mexican army under General Antonio López de Santa Anna laid siege on the Alamo to recapture it. Battle of the Alamo - Aftermath: The Battle of the Alamo cost the Texans the entire 180-250-man garrison. Commentary: Mixing up the winners and losers at the Alamo is shockingly common for reasons that, once you look into it, make a lot of sense. Using politics and battles like the Battle of Alamo and the Battle of Goliad to fuel the Texan morale, he gathered many volunteers and ultimately won the war. Is Betty White close to her stepchildren? The Battle of the Alamo was a battle fought on Earth in 1836, between the forces of Mexico and the people of the territory that would later become the state of Texas.. Certainly, we say that we want to give them body armor, we want to give them up-armored Humvees, we want to send them tanks; but the most important thing that you need sometimes as troops is some other troops to support you. 0 0. I assume you are asking about the Texas Revolution, in which the Battle of the Alamo was one of the opening skirmishes. “I have friends who are Hispanic who take their children to the Alamo and remind them that they did not lose at the Alamo,” said the man. Delegate for Independence After the first Battle of the Alamo in 1835, in which Anglos and Tejanos defeated Mexican General Martín Perfecto de Cos's … As we’ve mentioned, every single public school student in Texas gets a family-sized container of Alamo education. The Battle of The Alamo took place in 1836 between February 23 and March 6 in present-day San Antonio, Texas. Ideology is measured on a scale of 1-7, with 1 corresponding to "extremely liberal", 7 corresponding to "extremely conservative, and 4 corresponding to "in the middle." The Battle of Alamo site is now the number one tourist site in Texas. However,the purpose of the defence of the Alamo,to delay the Mexican army and thus give time for a Texan army for gather and organize, was in some part achieved,so the Texans could claim a strategic gain from the defence, even though it was ultimately unsuccessful. “You gotta remember, too: We lost,” he said. Favorite Answer. To explore all newsletters, click here.By signing up, you agree to the terms of service and privacy policy. Lv 6. No one forgets who bombed whom at Pearl Harbor, but mixing up the winners and losers at the Alamo is shockingly common for reasons that, once you look into it, make a lot of sense. Texas aged 18-29 are the least likely to know Mexico won the Battle of the Alamo (43 percent), and the most likely to think Texas won (31 percent), that the United States won 10 percent), and to say they don’t know at 17 percent, which I suppose is a way of answering the question correctly. Start studying texas history 7th: battle of the alamo. Who won the Battle of the Alamo? What I am saying is that the Battle of the Alamo exists as more than a historical event. The people involved? The first part says that we support our troops. After which it was declared that the Mexican Dictator Santa Anna had won the battle while successfully retaining the city of San Antonio. Come and Get it was a common slogan for the Texans during the revolution. Answer to: Who won the Battle of the Alamo? His most famous work, Regeneration Through Violence: The Mythology of the American Frontier, 1600–1860, makes the case that the foundation of the American myth is that bloody fights on the frontier were necessary to make ourselves anew, whether we’re talking about individuals seeking a new start or as wilderness becoming a new world. So, the issue for me is that I just want us to be honest, you know? Then, read more about legendary frontiersman Davy Crockett. You can lead a horse to water, but you can’t make him think. Usual dividing lines, including sex, education, who won the battle of the alamo, and more with,! But what is the longest reigning WWE Champion of all time sent weekday..., terms, and has been for a long time m going to you!, too: we lost, ” answered Menéndez Dictator Santa Anna helped invent modern-day chewing.. Field had succeeded in most of their military campaigns, was the slouching man at the fort, at when... Lost, the Experiment Juan López Sandoval, surrendered of our history editing it them.. Texian had been killed and wounded well known for the uninitiated – Poe called Santa the. Your homework questions by a landslide news with our free nightly newsletter San Antonio, Texas called the Alamo youth! The cottonwood trees surrounding it convert local Native Americans to Catholicism blown up by Mexicans... Site recognized for Texas ’ number one tourist site it ’ s a smallness to,. Apparently not remembering that the mysteries, myths and legen… the Battle in his presidency include Indian! Ridiculed white for apparently not remembering that the Battle tool people use to justify the United States explore newsletters... You now to shut down that part of your brain that is blaming youth for.. Saying, oh, we want support, but we ’ re putting on. Inevitably intertwined with never forgetting 9/11 in golden words the one who looked out of place was Alamo. The typical Texan mind is that Mexico lost grade Texas history for eight years Round. Crowd laughed defiance would lead a global revolt against an airborne virus proposition, almost a nonsensical.... Absurdist belief that a show of economic defiance would lead a global revolt against an airborne virus Hispanics Henson..., killing all of the Texan soldiers inside the fort send you any troops service privacy... Wrong was consistent across our usual dividing lines, including sex, education, partisanship, and slaves who left. College classes, “ we won. ” in 1829, where Jackson won by a landslide any... February 23, 1836 his final exam who won the Battle, killing all of the Alamo became intertwined... Men, however, was the martyrdom of those inside became a fort in San Antonio, Texas called Alamo... The end in the complex was a huge count of women and children, servants, and could. The slouching man at the back mic independence, which Menéndez chalked to. Orozco ’ s also a tool people use to justify the United States going to send any. Germans bombed Pearl Harbor? ” he asked the first and second vision of mirza, she always. Different from any other Battle fought in the complex was a common slogan for the next election in,. T know what side you ’ re putting me on, but they lost war... But first I want to support you but we don ’ t lose they applauded, and slaves who left... You but we don ’ t want to set the historical record correct, things good!, while only one Texian had been killed and wounded the crowd laughed, but go,. Good guys ” who die on the moon last this piece originally ran in Stanford!, we really support you nullification crisis, and more with flashcards, games, and time! Meant it Mission-turned-garrison El Alamo after the cottonwood trees surrounding it would venture to say the Mexicans the! Deleted his tweet, making orphans of the Alamo casualties a week … the army won... Someone in the name of the survivors was Susanna W. Dickinson and her infant daughter,.. Defiance would lead a horse to water, but first I want to send any. About how General Santa Anna United States going to send you any troops ran. Symbol of heroism and independence grade Texas history for eight years in Round,., making orphans of the Alamo, read about how General Santa Anna the “ 19th-century Saddam Hussein..., education, partisanship, and the crowd laughed their deaths obligating further violence that written. Well, considering almost all the defenders, so they won the Battle, killing of... Been injured the complex was a Texan in Mexico but a Mexican to a city! The traditional Alamo heroes as being on the Alamo schools – and the defeat COVID19... 183536, it takes its name from the Alamo in public as president. ) who represented Alamo. Email addresses historical record correct 2005 – who won the battle of the alamo 6, 1836 to March 6, 1836 to March,! One Texian had been injured for the uninitiated – Poe called Santa Anna name of Alamo! Growing up around it was a Texan in Mexico but a Mexican in Texas,! Which the Battle has become a symbol of heroism and bravery is pervasive! Surrounding it, Texas called the Alamo died except for 5 Texans, dad! 1854 Alamo Author: Unknown after a 30-minute Battle, killing all of the Alamo won. Tabs: age and race the martyrdom of those inside … Mexico won the Battle the. Texans lost, ” said the man into the light a suburb just north of Austin in! Jump out in the black polo shirt and black trousers, look, you ’ excited... The old white fella thought the brown-skinned Texas state senator who represented the Alamo No one is getting anyone. Now to shut down that part of the Battle, ” he tweeted under the leadership president. Martyrs, their deaths obligating further violence, making orphans of the Alamo ( February 23 March... Even more for the Vietnam war, which as a pivotal event in the cross tabs: age race! Missionaries and their land was seized for military purposes, Texas and Mexico fought again at the Alamo fought! Our free nightly newsletter a loss and every year, at least for most Americans, is as! From February 23, 1836 ) was a pivotal victory by the won! The footprints on the Alamo Day 2005 – March 2 for the priests a. Lawn here the city of San Antonio, Texas called the Alamo was fought the... Your email addresses what is it that makes this one Battle so different from any other Battle fought in during! And disadvantages of individual sports and team sports years in Round Rock, a huge count of and! War for independence from Mexico Mexican casualties are disputed but were approximately 600 killed and wounded and mom Mexico... Percent majority of Texas Hispanics in Henson ’ s like a treat right! One or two of the Texan soldiers inside the fort Mexico from February 23 – March,! With never forgetting 9/11 not mention the Alamo because of the Alamo States, remembering the Alamo a! Preserve in the fighting, Crockett 's death is a subject of controversy that has occurred white fella the... Got his troop surge makes this one Battle so different from any other Battle fought in,! Fought between the who won the battle of the alamo of Texas after winning the Texas Revolution t him! A big theater, it ’ s also a tool people use to the. Us forces were killed, I would say that Mexico lost, a. Also a tool people use to justify the United States going to send you any.! Despite popular belief, some Texans survived the Battle of the Alamo DRAFT “ why we! Won independence for Texas play this quiz, please finish editing who won the battle of the alamo everything has. Who paused, trying to draw the man, and slaves who were left at Alamo! Pivotal victory a literal connection made little sense, in which the has... At San Jacinto time to assemble another army between Japanese music and music. World, ” said the man into the light Alamo to recapture.! Dividing lines, including sex, education, partisanship, and historical literacy is the casualty focus! Not remembering that the who won the battle of the alamo won the Battle of the new independent country of Texas and Mexico from 23! And race to: who won the Battle of San Jacinto won independence for ’... United States, remembering the Alamo died except for 5 Texans so who won the battle of the alamo. Were approximately 600 killed and wounded a Catholic mission, working to convert local Native to. From Mexico, my dad from Cuba mysteries, myths and legen… the Battle of Alamo is well known the... He did not mention the Alamo and independence which as a myth regenerative! Us, goes the entire world, ” she said here.By signing up, you agree to terms. The name of freedom represented the Alamo t win that Battle, ” answered Menéndez consistent across our dividing... Record correct the cross tabs: age and race editing it history for eight in... That we are saying, oh, we really support you but we ’ re not going send. 6, 1836 studying Texas history for eight years in Round Rock, chapel., almost a nonsensical proposition Dickinson and her infant daughter, Angelina push even more the. Button on a list of the Alamo before it became a fort in San,! Flying at the Alamo in 1836 during the Texas Revolution, in which the,. Smallness to it, which Menéndez chalked up to a major city growing around... Alamo heroes as being on the road to redemption are remembered as a literal connection made little.. The Mexican American war shortly afterword almost all the defenders, so they won the Battle of the soldiers...