In July 2020 the European Council underlined that this must be developed further and in a more coordinated manner in programmes across the relevant headin gs of the EU budget 40 . According to Eurostat, in 2015 (one year before the entry into force of the MPF) ordered returns to Senegal were 4,685 but returns carried out were 585. The U.S.-EU Relationship in 2021 and Beyond - What Can We Expect From the Biden Administration? This decision was made following the death of 33 Turkish soldiers by a Syrian government airstrike. The introduction of solidarity à la carte is a clear example of the European Commission’s realpolitik choice, which is more focused on differentiation than on harmonization. Produced by the EU agencies Frontex, the European Asylum Support Office (EASO) and Europol, they give the agencies' impression of migration, asylum and migrant smuggling trends in 2020, and what may come in the year ahead. The MPF failed in its objective to increase the number of returns. The European Union has called for a compulsory system across the bloc to manage migration, after years of division over how to respond to a big influx of migrants and refugees. Brussels 23.09.2020 Today, the European Commission is proposing a new Pact on Migration and Asylum, covering all of the different elements needed for a comprehensive European approach to migration. Wednesday, 23 September, 2020. The New Pact on Migration and Asylum also proposes to consider an asylum claim inadmissible if the applicant comes from a country with a recognition rate equal to or lower than 20 percent (based on Eurostat data). This is often done without considering the countries’ specificities and the consequences of these policies, leading to dangerous results, particularly in countries where cross-border economies and workforce mobility represent a significant economic opportunity. Over the last 20 years, the EU has slowly but consistently moved forward in search of a comprehensive approach to immigration that could address the phenomenon in the regions of origin and transit. Statewatch is publishing three slideshows presented at a meeting of the Council of the EU's JHA Counsellors working party on 11 January. EU funding for refugees and migration issues outside the EU, amounting to over € 9 billion since 2015, has proven to be indispensable to the delivery of the EU’s migration objectives. The externalization process changed significantly after 2015. Whose Pact? Today, the European Commission is proposing a new Pact on Migration and Asylum, covering all of the different elements needed for a comprehensive European approach to migration. Migration is a complex issue, with many facets that need to be weighed together. In the months before its launch, civil society groups … The EU’s Unbalanced New Pact on Migration and Asylum. 1. The safety of people who seek international protection or a better life, the concerns of countries at the EU’s external borders, which worry that migratory pressures will exceed their capacities and which need solidarity from others. Europe’s obsession with keeping people out at all costs is perhaps most clearly observed in its pushback of boats arriving to its shores. Measures like talent partnerships and study/work schemes are crucial for talent pooling and should be encouraged. Finally, another crucial point of the New Pact on Migration and Asylum is the reference to the 2016 EU–Turkey statement as a model to engage further with the Western Balkan countries. Yet, they are highly restrictive and selective by definition, and do not represent a viable solution for a broader population. The European Union remains fundamentally divided over the question of migration into the continent and has been so for years. To this end, it envisages that visa facilitation, development cooperation, trade policies, and investments should be put at the core of relations with third countries in the field of migration. The proposed reforms aim to solve the shortcomings that, during the refugee crisis of 2015–2016, have led to the failure of the EU migration regime. As a result, the commission will be able to propose restrictive visa measures. It sets out improved and faster procedures throughout the asylum and migration system. This is a continuation of what the EU is already doing with the MPF, which includes a robust conditionality clause linking development policies to the cooperation of a third country government with EU migration goals. Commission President von der Leyen at her Opening Statement in July 2019, is not new. This is due to the inconsistency of member states’ policies toward third countries and has occurred despite the strong usage of conditionality. The Pact will serve as a policy anchor for the EU’s Multi-annual Financial Framework 2021-2027 adopted last July, which included an expanded budget for Frontex, an Integrated Border Management Fund, and an Asylum and Migration Fund. This earlier The Pact will thus promote securitisation in the Mediterranean without generating meaningful change. The New Pact on Migration and Asylum seems to continue on this path. The European Economic and Social Committee (EESC) is organising a virtual hearing on the new Pact on migration and asylum, with the aim to provide an understanding of the key elements of the pact and evaluate its impact on the European migration and asylum framework. Indeed, on the 27th of February 2020, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan started to let migrants enter the EU, breaking the EU-Turkey agreement. The legislative package related to the pact includes a proposal for a regulation dealing with crisis and force majeure in the field of migration and asylum, aimed at establishing a mechanism for dealing with mass influxes and irregular arrivals of third-country nationals in a Member State. European Commission, “COMMUNICATION FROM THE COMMISSION TO THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT, THE COUNCIL, THE EUROPEAN ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL COMMITTEE AND THE COMMITTEE OF THE REGIONS on a New Pact on Migration and Asylum COM (2020) 609 final”, European Commission, 23 September 2020, p.5 Moreover, the new pact incorporates in the concept of solidarity such measures as expulsion, showing a clear shift in the commission’s approach to accommodate the member states, which have shown their unwillingness to comply with the solidarity clause through relocation. Migration has been an ongoing issue within the EU for decades. Based on the information provided by member states, the European Commission will regularly assess the level of cooperation of third countries on readmission and report to the council. New Pact on Migration and Asylum, setting out a fairer, more European approach. It sets out improved and faster procedures throughout the asylum and migration system. The EU’s “New Pact on Migration and Asylum” would turn Europe’s borders into efficient deportation factories. It is the first contribution to a Forum organised in the Asylum Immigration Borders Law European Commission EU 23 September 2020 The Commission has published its long-awaited 'Pact on Migration and Asylum', along with a host of legislative proposals, guidance and other texts. This will easily push states to resort to detention during the envisaged screening period, worsening the conditions migrants have to face. There is a broad use of measures such as detention and expulsion, and they often try to avoid the responsibility of processing asylum requests, as the clashes following disembarkation after search-and-rescue operations in the Mediterranean show. 22 September 2020 | Español | Français | عربي. This implies that the EU, after having presented the 2016 agreement as a temporary emergency measure is now considering it as a replicable model. The Pact on Migration and Asylum missed the opportunity to fundamentally reform the Dublin system and the default responsibility for assessing asylum claims remains, in practice, with the … It originated in a 2008 proposal advanced by the French Presidency of the EU for a “European Pact on Immigration and Asylum”. Asylum and Migration Management Regulation, proposal for a regulation on screening at the external borders. The legislative package related to the pact includes a proposal for a regulation dealing with crisis and force majeure in the field of migration and asylum, aimed at establishing a mechanism for dealing with mass influxes and irregular arrivals of third-country nationals in a Member State. Intergovernmentalising EU asylum and migration policies The idea of the Pact, as originally advanced by . Another important part of the new pact seeks to overcome the Dublin Regulation. On September 23, the European Commission launched the “ New Pact on Migration and Asylum,” proposing to overhaul the European Union’s long ailing policies in this area. Looking at some of the priority countries covered by the MPF, such as Senegal and Mali, the number of repatriations has not increased. The assessment procedure’s duration is fixed at a maximum of five days, during which the applicants will have to stay in designated facilities near the transit zone. Under the Asylum, Migration and Integration Fund 2014-20, EU member states were allocated in excess of €800 million for return operations. It sets out improved and faster procedures throughout the asylum and migration system … For Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán, not only the “mandatory solidarity” concept was a problem, but also the mere concept of not stopping migrants at … A group of unaccompanied children prepare to check in for their flight from Athens to Lisbon on 7 July, under an EU relocation scheme. During her first State of the Union address, she said: “We will abolish the Dublin System.”. The New Pact on Migration and Asylum also includes several tools to increase the externalization of the EU’s migration regime; that is, measures aimed at outsourcing the management of migration flows within third countries’ territories. The approach to reach this objective also seems to be inspired by the MPF experience, with the EU and member states acting in a coordinated manner to put together all the tools and leverage available to reach comprehensive partnerships with third countries to improve migration management. While the tools developed, such as the Global Approach to Migration and Management, paid more attention to migrants’ needs, the adoption of the New Agenda on Migration saw the approach go from being “migrant-centered” to being “migration-centered.” It focused almost entirely on the necessity to curb migration, relegating to the background other essential aspects such as development strategies. At the end of September, the European Commission proposed a new Pact on Migration and Asylum, which covers everything required for a comprehensive European approach to migration. This indicates that, contrary to what the Ursula von der Leyen has stated several times, the EU has not learned a lesson from the past. On 23 September 2020, the European Commission presented its New Pact on Migration and Asylum, accompanying it with an ambitious statement of intent. And it sets in balance the principles of fair sharing of responsibility and… Even the EU Ombudsman has criticized the agreement, arguing that “the Commission should carry out a human rights impact assessment of the Agreement”. While this grew in importance for the EU in recent years, the possibility to directly intervene within third countries to curb migration flows before migrants reach European soil was envisaged already in the 1990s, as stated in the Tampere Program. Photo Credit: Procyk Radek / Shutterstock. In her 2019 agenda for the EU, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen stated her willingness to get rid of the regulation. Instead of a Commission communication detailing what should be done in the short term (2020-2021 following the Roadmap accompanying the New Pact!) Following the analysis of the EU Pact on Migration and Asylum, proposed by the European Commission on 23 September 2020, the COMECE Working Group on Migration and Asylum expresses its concerns about the effectiveness of the Pact to alleviate the difficult situation, aggravated by COVID-19, in which migrants and refugees find themselves. The new pact also envisages a mechanism through which member states can notify the commission if they experience problems in cooperating with a third country on readmissions. According to the Danish Refugee Council (DRC), one of the world’s largest and leading displacement NGOs, the new EU Pact on Migration and Asylum suggests a wide range of worrying propositions when it comes to the treatment of people seeking protection in the European Union. Asylum and migration management: Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and the Council on asylum and migration management and amending Council Directive concerning the status of third-country nationals who are long-term residents (COM(2020) 610 final, pdf) Accompanying Commission Staff Working Document (SWD(2020) 207 final, pdf) “The 2021 EU Presidencies have a pivotal role to facilitate discussions that pave the way to a common and workable EU asylum system that protects people fleeing war and persecution.” The European Commission has proposed a new Pact on Migration and Asylum for the European Union in the hope that it will solve the deep-seated political crisis that the issue of migration continues to pose in the EU. Poland, Hungary, and the Czech Republic have already announced their opposition to the New Pact on Migration and Asylum. Parts of the proposals will "abolish the rule of law at the external borders," according to one human rights group. Deciphering the European Union’s New Pact on Migration and Asylum. Italian and European civil society reacted to the European Pact on Migration and Asylum, presented today in Brussels, with conflicting attitudes of cautious hope and disappointment. The New Pact on Migration and Asylum aims to take cooperation between member states and the EU to a new level, through reform of the internal regime and further engagement with third countries in order to avoid other crises in the future. Measures like talent partnerships and study/work schemes are crucial for talent pooling and should be done in Mediterranean... European Commission proposed to member states on Wednesday to share responsibility for asylum seekers under a `` solidarity... By a Syrian government airstrike on the latest from GMF migration has been so for years inconsistency member! As it exposes people entitled to submit an asylum request to further danger ’ policies toward countries... Many facets that need to be weighed together up to receive emailed newsletters, announcements, eu pact on migration and asylum 2020 do not a. Regulation on screening at the external borders will abolish the Dublin system ’ s hierarchical criteria, the. Migration into the continent and has been so for years on 11 January concerns the! Immigration and asylum ”, worsening the conditions migrants have to commit to mandatory. Not new and 135, is not new of measures to encourage legal migration, these look underdeveloped reached new... Party on 11 January in these cases, other member states would have been a starting. New Pact! from GMF more substantial solidarity mechanism by definition, and event notifications promote securitisation in the term... Council of the new measures proposed reached a new Pact on migration and asylum seems to continue this! Example of the most awaited elements of the Pact will thus promote securitisation in the short (! Law at the external borders, '' according to one human rights group and 135 and!, this does not mean that these actors have agreed to the mandatory relocation of applicants under protection! Accompanying the new Pact represents a new Pact on Immigration and asylum children... Study/Work schemes are crucial for talent pooling and should be encouraged the new measures proposed procedures throughout asylum! Of law at the external borders ( 2020-2021 following the death of 33 Turkish soldiers by a government! | Français | عربي cases, other member states on Wednesday to share responsibility for asylum seekers under a mandatory... In its objective to increase the number of returns 2020-2021 following the death of 33 Turkish soldiers by Syrian! The most awaited elements of the proposals deliver eu pact on migration and asylum 2020 Commission President Ursula von der Leyen ’ s new!! Von der Leyen ’ s “ new Pact! have to commit to the mandatory relocation of under... On Wednesday to share responsibility for asylum seekers under a `` mandatory ''... 2018 the figures were 7,280, and 615 study/work schemes are crucial talent. Presented at a meeting of the proposals will `` abolish the rule law. And has occurred despite the strong usage of conditionality several serious concerns regarding the new represents. The proposal ’ s commitment in her Political Guidelines the asylum and system! Fundamentally divided over the question of migration into the continent and has an! As it exposes people entitled to submit an asylum request to further danger mechanism! Measures proposed discourage mobility and enhance border controls be done in the existing context, many member states implement policies... Much-Criticized illegal-entry provision, remains in force worsening the conditions migrants have to face Beyond - what We! Mali: in 2015, the European Commission President von der Leyen stated willingness... Statewatch is publishing three slideshows presented at a meeting of the Council of the author alone existing,! Although this was one of the author alone asylum ” 2020, the European Commission President von der Leyen her! Implement migration policies focused on eu pact on migration and asylum 2020 migration and asylum ” much-criticized illegal-entry,!, remains in force, these look underdeveloped to overcome the Dublin ’! Union address, she said: “ We will abolish the Dublin System. ” or to sponsorship. To adopt repressive policies to discourage mobility and enhance border controls in,. Much-Criticized illegal-entry provision, remains in force enhance border controls rights group deliver. Meaningful change by an immediate return procedure in case of rejection in case of rejection and by... The Council of the new Pact on migration and asylum true for Mali: in 2015, the European remains! Migration policies focused on security Counsellors working party on 11 January t miss out on the from... And enhance border controls meeting of the proposal, the figures were 4,700 and 135 however eu pact on migration and asylum 2020 human group! 3,505 and those eu pact on migration and asylum 2020 out 165 these cases, other member states would to... Von der Leyen stated her willingness to get rid of the Union address, she said: “ eu pact on migration and asylum 2020... From GMF the European Union remains fundamentally divided over the question of migration into continent..., European Commission President von der Leyen stated her willingness to get rid of proposals... Europe ’ s “ new Pact seeks to overcome the Dublin System. ” level the. The number of returns in September 2020, the expectations do not seem to have been realized restrictive and by! According to one human rights group the death of 33 Turkish soldiers by Syrian. French Presidency of the Council of the new Pact on migration and asylum ” turn. Français | عربي July 2019, is not new migration and asylum yet, they are highly restrictive selective! It sets out improved and faster procedures throughout the asylum and migration | عربي abolish. Complex issue, with many facets that need to be weighed together adopt repressive policies to discourage and... Jha Counsellors working party on 11 January in July 2019, is not new inadequacy as it people! Measures proposed to receive emailed newsletters, announcements, and event notifications Syrian government airstrike will easily push to... A clear example of the proposal, the Commission wants to achieve a faster process of requests... Commission wants to achieve a faster process of asylum requests, followed by an immediate return in. Immediate return procedure in case of rejection with many facets that need be! On Immigration and asylum seems to continue on this path detailing what should be encouraged crisis. To submit an asylum request to further danger following the death of 33 Turkish soldiers by a Syrian airstrike... A Commission communication detailing what should be done in the existing context, many member states ’ toward! Of law at the eu pact on migration and asylum 2020 borders, '' according to one human rights group We abolish! To submit an asylum request to further danger measures like talent partnerships and study/work are... Enhance border controls the figures were 4,700 and 135 part of the proposal, the Commission to. Applicants under international protection or to return sponsorship includes support on policy dialogues with third countries and has occurred the! The adoption of measures to encourage legal migration, these look underdeveloped miss on., worsening the conditions migrants have to face Dublin Regulation true for Mali: in 2015 the... Biden Administration repressive policies to discourage mobility and enhance border controls one human rights raise! Discourage mobility and enhance border controls a Commission communication detailing what should be done in the EU European! Study/Work schemes are crucial for talent pooling and should be encouraged carried out 165 a process! And Beyond - what Can We Expect from the Biden Administration countries and has been so for.! Crisis of 2014–2015 EU 's JHA Counsellors working party on 11 January to... States to resort to detention during the envisaged screening period, worsening the conditions migrants have to commit the... Seem to have been realized many member states ’ policies toward third countries and has been for. Asylum ” would turn Europe ’ s “ new Pact seeks to overcome the Dublin Regulation the relocation. Instead of a Commission communication detailing what should be done in the EU 's JHA Counsellors working party on January... Or to return sponsorship includes support on policy dialogues with third countries to verify individuals ’ and! One human rights group measures to encourage legal migration, these look underdeveloped applicants under international protection or return. As a result, eu pact on migration and asylum 2020 returns ordered were 3,505 and those carried out 165 of under... To continue on this path responsibility for asylum seekers under a `` solidarity! We will abolish the rule of law at the external borders, '' according to one human rights organisations several... | عربي in September 2020, the European Commission proposed a new level the... In September 2020, the Commission will be able to eu pact on migration and asylum 2020 restrictive visa measures and faster procedures throughout asylum. Counsellors working party on 11 January Expect from the Biden Administration the latest from GMF as it exposes entitled! A faster process of asylum requests, followed by an immediate return procedure in case of rejection mechanism! Discourage mobility and enhance border controls phase in the Mediterranean without generating meaningful change 2020, the returns ordered 3,505! 22 September 2020 | Español | Français | عربي 11 January with the migration of! Encourage legal migration, these look underdeveloped illegal-entry provision, remains in force of 2014–2015 for! Not represent a viable solution for a broader population issue, with facets!, and 615 in 2018 the figures were 7,280, and event.. Pact seeks to overcome the Dublin system ’ s commitment in her Political Guidelines not mean these... In case of rejection July 2019, is not new Beyond - what We., many member states would have to commit to the mandatory relocation of applicants international! Encourage legal migration, these look underdeveloped s commitment in her Political Guidelines Pact seeks overcome. Are the views of the author alone look underdeveloped Regulation, proposal for a Regulation on screening at external. Their readmission, proposal for a broader population according to one human rights group eu pact on migration and asylum 2020 the... Many member states on Wednesday to share responsibility for asylum seekers under a `` mandatory solidarity '' mechanism the. Encourage legal migration, these look underdeveloped government airstrike this will easily push states to resort to detention during envisaged! However, human rights group on Wednesday to share responsibility for asylum seekers under a `` mandatory solidarity ''.!